Buying a horse can be a nightmare. OK, it can also just be a gimpy gelding.
You’ll often see ads that proudly declare that this horse is ready to go in any direction. I don’t want a horse that can go in any direction. I want a horse that goes in the direction I point it.
The well-known clinician Richard Winters will tell you a horse can go in four directions: backward, forward, up, and down. The horse pictured on the top right is going up (rearing). Coincidentally, in Richard Winters’ clinic, my horse Josie, whose registration is shown above, deposited me on my sorry ass by doing a 90-degree rear. If it had been more than 90 degrees, her sorry ass could have landed on me—not an appealing direction to go.
In short, a horse advertised as “ready to go in any direction” is almost certainly a green horse. A horse aged five or younger is likely green as well. Josie was five when I bought her.
Don’t buy a green horse unless you’re ready to spend more than you paid for the horse in training fees—or you truly have the skills to do the training yourself.
I asked my friend ChatGPT to analyze height frequency in current online ads for horse sales. I was not surprised to find that the most commonly advertised height is 14.3 hh.
Why was cynical me not surprised? Because the cutoff that separates horses from ponies is 14.2 hh. People shopping for a horse generally don’t want to buy a pony. I’m betting that many horses advertised at 14.3 hh are actually smaller and are, in fact, ponies.
I once went to see a horse advertised at 15.2 hh. I didn’t bring a measuring stick, but it was obvious he was smaller than advertised. I’m six feet tall and about 180 pounds. When I mounted him, he immediately went down on his knees. It was a very short test ride. Buy a horse measuring stick and bring it with you when you look at a horse. You will learn 2 things: its height and how comfortable it is with strange objects.

The first horse I owned was Bandito, a 16 hh registered Quarter Horse. I leased Bandito for about six months before I bought him. During that time, he never took a bad step—or I was too green to notice.
When his owner agreed to sell him to me, I took the advice of the stable manager and did not have Bandito vetted. He said, “Why pay to vet an obviously healthy horse you’ve ridden for six months?” Why indeed.
Bandito ended up having a very short useful riding life. He came up lame in the front during the first two years I owned him. He had developed navicular syndrome, which is expensive to diagnose and treat. He had two neurectomies—costly procedures that ablate the nerve transmitting pain from the damaged navicular bone. Unfortunately, the nerve grows back.
Bandito was retired when the nerve regrew for the second time. I spent far more on diagnostics, special shoeing, and neurectomies than I would have spent on a thorough pre-purchase exam. It’s likely that X-rays of his feet would have revealed the beginnings of navicular syndrome, as shown in the third photo above. If they had, I would not have purchased Bandito.
Get your prospective horse thoroughly vetted. If you can’t afford that, you probably can’t afford to own a horse.
I bought Josie from a friend who advertised her as a registered American Paint Horse. After the purchase, I asked for the registration papers. She had lost them. As you can see above, I eventually obtained a copy from the APHA, and my friend turned out to be truthful. Still, I should have asked for the papers before buying the horse.
Unfortunately, I did not learn my lesson from Josie. After she was retired. I went to look at a horse named Schooner, advertised as a registered Appendix Quarter Horse. The AQHA has an appendix for these horses, which are crosses between registered Thoroughbreds and registered Quarter Horses.
I liked Schooner, but felt he was a bit green. I told the alleged owner, I would first have Schooner vetted, then put a non-refundable deposit on him, and then complete the purchase after she put 3 more months of training on him.
At the exam, the vet immediately lifted the top lip. There, we saw a Jockey Club tattoo indicating that Schooner was not a registered Appendix but a purebred off-the-track Thoroughbred. Racing Appendix Quarter Horses also have lip tattoos, but in a different format. The vet asked the owner for the papers. The owner said she would retrieve them from her home. She came out and told us she could not find the papers, and that she was not the owner but was selling the horse for a friend! I walked away after paying the vet for a ranch call. This incident led to an interesting thread of emails, which I will excerpt below
At first, the Schooner incident stunned me, but then I got angry. The seller had misrepresented the horse’s breed,and its ownership, and I was out the vet’s ranch call fee. Also, at that time, I only had a B.S. in BS horse-for-sale ads. This incident qualified me for a Ph.D. Here are chronological excerpts from my email dissertation in cynicism:
Me to seller: Hope you are doing well. I think it would be reasonable for you to reimburse me the $115.00 ranch call. Even though it was an accident, Schooner was in fact misrepresented. I would not even have ridden him if I knew he was a TB, let alone order a prepurchase exam.
Seller to me: If you feel this strongly about TB’s and how prejudice you are against TB’s, I again apologize for posting the wrong breed. ….. an Appendix, which I advertised him as, Is MOSTLY thoroughbred!!!! (NO. It can be no more than 50% TB) So this big deal about Schooner being a TB is in my opinion, ludicrous. You acted like he was diseased or something. Totally a POS because he is a TB. .. wanted you to see why a “buy for the breed” or in this case, “not buying because of a breed” is ridiculous and close minded. I have never had this situation occur and hopefully never will again. (This trainer/dealer now has numerous online complaints for misrepresenting horses.) You opted out of buying a good horse simply because of his breed-NOT what he can do or how you connected with him!! I apologize for half way mistaking his breed- but I would think long and hard the situation as a whole. Schooner is amazing, no matter what his Breed!!! Oh btw, his grand sires are big time amazing horses- Northern Dancer and Seattle Slew. Google them! His own Sire is Gotham City, which sold for $2 million as a 2 yr old, is probably another POS TB right??!! (Gotham City was indeed sold for 2 million in 2000. He might have been a POS as he raced only twice, never won, and his stud fees totaled only about $520K. Not withstanding POS, his ROI was awful.) And I have numerous friends who own and rodeo off of horses bred this way both roping and barrels. TB’s have no cow sense??? I think we need to turn the table as who has sense here.
Me to seller: I am not surprised at this little piece of fiction you have worked out to make me the bad guy in all this. First of all, this has nothing to do with my prejudices or my opinion of Schooner. Yes, I never would have been interested in him if I knew he was a TB. In the normal world, we call that a preference, not a prejudice. Second anyone who buys a misrepresented horse from a dealer would have a few loose screws. I do not. There is a lot of trust that goes into buying a horse. You lost that…. You can keep telling yourself that you have the moral high ground here and keep digging a deeper hole at the same time, but all in all this attack on me is really sad.
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.